Mar 23, 3:56 PM EDT

Top Senate Dem opposes Supreme Court pick, vows filibuster

AP Photo
AP Photo/Susan Walsh

Supreme Court:
Other News
Preview: Supreme Court's 2006-2007 Term

2005-06 Term Highlights

Clickable Supreme Court

The High Court's New Seating Chart

The Death Penalty

Court Opinions
June 29: Court Blocks War Crimes Trials for Guantanamo Detainees (PDF)

June 29: Justices Uphold Arizona Insanity Law (PDF)

June 28: Court Nixes Part of Texas Redistricting Plan (PDF)

June 28: Justices Rule Against Foreign Suspects (PDF)

June 28: Court Rules States Can Keep Newspapers From Some Inmates (PDF)

June 26: Court Rejects Vt. Campaign Finance Law (PDF)

June 26: Court Upholds Kan. Death Penalty Law (PDF)

June 19: Court Rules Parolees Can Be Searched Without Cause (PDF)

June 19: Court Holds Victims' Statements Admissible if Made in Emergencies (PDF)

June 19: Court Splits on Wetlands Protection (PDF)

June 15: Court Backs Police No-Knock Searches (PDF)

June 12: Court Allows Lethal Injection Challenges (PDF)

May 1: Court Backs Ex-Playmate's Effort to Pursue Part of Late Husband's Fortune (PDF)

April 17: Court Backs Immigration Officials (PDF)

Mar. 22: Roberts Dissents in Police Search Case (PDF)

Mar. 6: Court Upholds Campus Military Recruiting (PDF)

Feb. 28: Court Throws Out Gas Prices Suit (PDF)

Feb. 28: Court Backs Abortion Protesters (PDF)

Feb. 22: Woman Who Tripped on Mail Can Sue Postal Service (PDF)

Feb. 22: Discrimination Suit Against Pizza Chain Denied (PDF)

Feb. 22: Court Rules Restaurant Must Pay Employee for Sex Discrimination (PDF)

Feb. 22: Court Rules Captial Murder Defendants Have No Right to Alibi Evidence at Sentencing (PDF)

Feb. 21: Court Upholds Use of Hallucinogenic Tea in Religious Rites (PDF)

Oral Arguments on Guantanamo Detainees: Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, March 28, 2006
Buy AP Photo Reprints
2006 Senate Races

2006 House Races

2006 Governor Races

2006 Ballot Initiatives

Election News
State Sen. Biss says he's running for Illinois governor

How the GenForward poll of young Americans was conducted

Official: Sanders shares blame for minors voting in primary

Postelection dominoes create 5 open House seats

Libertarian Party earns political party status in Iowa

Democratic effort led by ex-AG Holder targets swing states

Feds rescind opposition to key part of Texas voter ID law

Lawyer: White House to no longer contest Texas' voter ID law

Judge asks US election commission to weigh in on lawsuit

How the AP-NORC poll of teenagers was conducted

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The top Senate Democrat said Thursday he will oppose President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee and lead a filibuster of the choice, setting up a politically charged showdown with Republicans with far-reaching implications for future judicial nominees.

New York Sen. Chuck Schumer criticized Judge Neil Gorsuch, saying he "almost instinctively favors the powerful over the weak" and would not serve as a check on Trump or be a mainstream justice.

"I have concluded that I cannot support Neil Gorsuch's nomination," Schumer said on the Senate floor. "My vote will be no and I urge my colleagues to do the same."

Shortly before Schumer's announcement, Pennsylvania Sen. Bob Casey, who faces re-election next year in a state Trump won, also announced his opposition. Casey said he had "serious concerns about Judge Gorsuch's rigid and restrictive judicial philosophy, manifest in a number of opinions he has written on the 10th Circuit." Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., also announced he would oppose Gorsuch.

Democrats are still furious that Republicans blocked former President Barack Obama's nominee, Merrick Garland, and the seat on the high court has remained vacant for 13 months and counting. The GOP insisted that the next president make the nomination.

Liberals have pressured Democrats to resist all things Trump, including his nominees, although Gorsuch emerged unscathed from two days of testifying.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., now must decide whether to take the same step his Democratic predecessor did and change Senate rules to confirm Gorsuch and other Supreme Court nominees with a simple majority rather than the 60 votes now required to move forward.

"Gorsuch will be confirmed; I just can't tell you exactly how that will happen, yet," McConnell said in an interview with The Associated Press earlier this week.

The Judiciary panel is expected to vote in the next two weeks to recommend Gorsuch favorably to the full Senate.

White House spokesman Sean Spicer called Schumer's announcement disappointing and said it breaks with the tradition of how the Senate has handled Supreme Court confirmation votes in modern times.

Democrats Jeff Merkley of Oregon, Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, Sherrod Brown of Ohio, Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Ed Markey of Massachusetts have declared their opposition.

No Democrat has yet pledged to support the judge, but Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia said Wednesday he is open to voting for him.

Hearings for a Supreme Court nominee usually dominate Congress, but that's not been the case over the four days of hearings. The Republican push to dismantle Obama's Affordable Care Act and the controversy surrounding the investigation into contact between Trump associates and Russia overshadowed the hearings.

On Thursday, lawyers, advocacy groups and former colleagues got their say on Gorsuch. Critics said he tended to rule for powerful interests and against workers, the disabled and environmental groups, but those who worked with him over the years sought to assure senators that he goes into each case committed to hearing and evaluating all points of view before making up his mind.

The American Bar Association's Nancy Scott Degan explained how a committee evaluating Gorsuch came up with its highest rating of well qualified. She said the committee contacted almost 5,000 people nationwide who might have knowledge of his qualifications. They examined his qualifications based on integrity, professional competence and temperament.

"The scope of our investigation was deep and broad," Degan said. "We do not give the well-qualified rating lightly."

Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., also noted that Garland received the ABA's well-qualified rating, but didn't get a hearing. Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah said he agreed that Garland is a wonderful person and well qualified.

Retired U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Deanell Reece Tacha served with Gorsuch and told senators he brings to the bench a powerful intellect and does not use his role as judge for anything other than deciding the case before him.

Some witnesses who were critical of Gorsuch worried that he would not be a strong check on executive overreach. Elisa Massimino, president and CEO of Human Rights First, described him as someone "who wouldn't stand up against a presidential power grab," stemming from his service in the Justice Department during the Bush administration. And a Colorado man criticized Gorsuch for ruling against his autistic son in a case, saying Gorsuch's opinion eviscerated the minimal education requirements schools must provide disabled children.


Associated Press writer Mary Clare Jalonick contributed to this report.

© 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Learn more about our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Latest News